Definitions of Tempomorphic Performance
Reflecting its concern with temporal issues, this investigation is divided into three sections: past, addressing the need for research; present, including extant examples and observations regarding research methodology; and future, addressing implications of issues discussed.
1 Past: the need for research
1.1 Temporal perception
The meanings of music are temporal owing to music's unique ability to create different kinds of time, often simultaneously, which resonate with the nonlinearity (and linearity) of our inner thought processes as well as with the linearity (and nonlinearity) of our external lives in society (Kramer, 1988: 15).
Of the two kinds of time referred to here, that of the individual and that of society, social temporality will be addressed first.
A precedent for perceived temporal hierarchies is found in existing literature referring to a communal, objective time which is co-existent with the subjective time of the individual. Objective time has been described as a ‘public neutral object’ by Bertrand Russell (1967: 9), while Martin Heidegger (1995: 464) has shown that ‘Everyman’ directs him or herself ‘according to it’. The subjective temporal perceptions of the individual are governed, according to the laws of thermodynamics, by the psychological arrow of time (Hawking, 1988: 145). It is the psychological arrow of time which supplies us with a sense of duration. The subjective distortion of durations from their objective time norm has been referred to by Igor Stravinsky as ‘psychological time’ (Kramer, 1988: 454). These durations are not necessarily the same in each individual, a reminder of the reliability of subjective awareness questioned perhaps most famously by René Descartes (1994: 76). However, attempts to quantify the psychological present have supplied a measurement of approximately ‘3 seconds’:
This discussion [of the measurement of subjective duration] in turn leads to the phenomenon of the 'psychological present', which is the critical period of time within which we can perceive and organize a succession of events. Though it is not an absolute time period, roughly 3 seconds seems to represent this critical present. Fraisse, citing other studies, points out that the average length of a musical bar in religious hymns is 3.4 sec. The average duration of a line of poetry is 2.7 sec. Further examples (not cited by Fraisse): Most musical motives fit this 3-second period, as do most minimal phrases in language (Epstein, 1995: 510-11).
A development of the idea of more than one temporality is found in the results of investigations into theories of timeworlds, or ‘Umwelts’.  Jokob von UexKüll (1921), J.T. Fraser (1982), and Johnathan Kramer (1988) (representing the respective disciplines of biology, philosophy, and musicology) show a line of evolving research concerned with species-specific temporal hierarchies and their interdisciplinary representation (see table below).
Table 1 demonstrates relationships of hierarchical levels between the biological theories of von UexKüll, the temporal theories of Fraser, and the musical interpretations of temporalities suggested by Kramer. Kramer has pointed out that theories of hierarchical temporality described by Fraser help us to understand musical concepts such as ‘vertical’ and non-linear (Kramer, 1988: 394).
The development of umwelt theory also reflects the development of an interdisciplinary aesthetic with possible implications for investigative methodologies. One such implication is that the study of tempomorphics may benefit from the use of models from more than one discipline. Further evidence supporting alternative evaluations of passing time reflects cultural values, establishing categories including sacred, biological, and polychronic time is provided by Edward Hall (1984: 13). (See table 2).
Table 2: Hall’s categories of time
The interest in temporal concepts has been seen as a characteristic of twentieth-century aesthetics. As James Gleick observes in Faster (1999: 7), aesthetic attention to the temporal dimension has dominated the twentieth century, as the eighteenth century concerned itself with the understanding of mass, and the nineteenth century is characterised by the spatial conquest of the globe. Perhaps reflecting advances in the physical sciences occasioned by Albert Einstein’s theory of relativity, time in the 1900s has ‘swept to the foreground of twentieth-century art’ (Mitchell, 1963: 74).
It may be noted from these observations that twentieth-century performers and their audience share a developed awareness of temporality. However, because temporality is a cognitive phenomenon, any impact performance derives from temporal perception will be in the way the performer uses aesthetic language to inform his or her work, in addition to the prior aesthetic precepts of the audience. In his appraisal of perceptual hierarchies at work in Western art music, David Epstein has identified levels of beat and pulse, measure and motive, hypermeasure and phrase conveyed in through-composed musics, any and all of which require the presence of a conductor to aid ensemble performance (1995: 29-35).
To conclude this brief survey of issues relating to the perception of temporality, we see a variety of contributing factors to the subject’s perception of passing time in the experience of music. Social values and individual interpretation of information received aurally have been challenged and highlighted by works such as John Cage’s ‘4’. 33”’(1976).
1.2 Musical developments
It is necessary to address the resulting communication of meaning conveyed by a given example of music to the listener, noting that such meaning depends at least in part on an aesthetic interpretation on behalf of the audience. Two observations by composers of the twentieth century serve to remind us of the problems related to identifying meaning in music. Stravinsky’s famous comment that music is ‘powerless to express anything at all’ (Griffiths, 1994: 63) serves as an answer to the question which, in Aaron Copland’s opinion, ‘should never have been asked’ (1952: 13). Elsewhere the problems presented by the study of hearing are attributed to individual abilities of perception and cognition in the listener. The competence of the listener, including the ‘sociology of taste’, is challenged by the organisation of musical structure (Wellek, 1979: 115-21). The point Wellek makes has similarities with that made by Ernst Gombrich regarding the ‘innocent eye’ and, to paraphrase the art historian, the share of the artwork taken by the beholder (Gombrich, 1968: 169).
Concluding this overview addressing issues of meaning in music, the importance of temporal issues in relation to the organisation of music (and the cognition of that organisation) is emphasised. According to Stravinsky, after refuting the musical power of expression, ‘[t]he phenomenon of music is given to us with the sole purpose of establishing an order in things, including, and particularly, the coordination between man and time,’ (quoted in Griffiths, 1994: 63). Furthermore, in The Role of Timing Patterns in Recognition of Emotional Expression, it is argued that timing is often regarded as the most fundamental aspect of musical performance, in addition to the perceived operation of different hierarchical levels denoted by temporal patterns in music (Juslin and Madison, 1999: 197-221).
Changes in aesthetic interpretation of music in society discussed above have contributed to an emergent style of music-making, an example of which is ‘Ambient’ music, named by Brian Eno (1996: 293). Eno is quoted here to supply a description of cultural conditions giving rise to his style of ambient music:
In 1978 I released the first record which described itself as Ambient Music, a name I invented to describe an emerging musical style.
It happened like this. In the early seventies, more and more people were changing the way they were listening to music. Records and radio had been around long enough for the novelty to wear off, and people were wanting to make quite particular and sophisticated choices about what they played in their homes and workplaces, what kind of sonic mood they surrounded themselves with. […] I was noticing that my friends and I were making and exchanging long cassettes of music chosen for its stillness, homogeneity, lack of surprises and, most of all, lack of variety. We wanted to use music in a different way – as part of the ambience of our lives – and we wanted it to be continuous, a surrounding (Eno, 1996: 293).
The ambient style finds musical precedence in the early twentieth-century furniture music of Erik Satie and ‘Les Six’ (Griffiths, 1994: 68). Modern music, Griffiths tells us conveniently, commenced with Debussy’s flute melody in his ‘Prelude a ‘L’apres-midi d’un faun’ (1892-4) (Griffiths, 1994: 4), while the origins of ambient music has been identified among the works of Mahler (Prendergast, 2001: 4). It is possible that the location of a future style of music in the work of a composer of the previous century reflects evidence supporting theories of the ‘hermeneutic circle’ as much as aesthetic and stylistic musical development. 
One (perhaps the first) example of ambient music – Eno’s Ambient 1: Music for airports – is a realisation of Debussy’s concern with providing music for the century of the aeroplane (Prendergast, 2000: 3). The ethos of ambient music features elements Heinrich Schenker, in marked contrast to Debussy, suggests should be omitted from music:
The life of a motif is represented in an analogous way. The motif is led through various situations. At one time, its melodic character may be tested; at another time, a harmonic peculiarity must prove its valour in unaccustomed surroundings; a third time, again, the motif is subjected to some rhythmic change: in other words, the motif lives through its fate, like a personage in a drama. […] Thus it is illicit, according to the laws of abbreviation, to present the motif in a situation which cannot contribute anything new to the clarification of its character. No composer could hope to reveal through overloaded, complicated, and unessential matter what could be revealed by few, well-chosen, fatal moments in the life of a motif. It will be of no interest at all to hear how the motif, metaphorically speaking, makes its regular evening toilet, takes its regular lunch, etc (Schenker, 1973: 13).
Schenker's emphasis here is on the syntactical representation of dramatic narrative. However, interdisciplinary aesthetics of the twentieth century developed the abandonment of narrative, producing, according to one observer, a style characterised by 'no texture, no drawing, no light, no space, no movement, no object, no subject, no symbol, no form...no pleasure, no pain' (Reinhardt, quoted by Polin, 1989: 226). This Minimalist style, especially in the promotion of a non-narrative aesthetic, underpins music composed and performed to function as a background to the regular toilet and lunch of the international traveller in the environment of the airport (Eno, 1996: 295).
In order to identify how performance technique has incorporated aesthetic considerations discussed above, it is necessary to define conventional performance.
A recorded example of conventional performance displaying cultural text, instrumental virtuosity of the solo artist, the use of technology, and improvisation in performance is Jimi Hendrix’s ‘Star Spangled Banner’ (1994). Comparison to performance models indicating requirements to achieve expression (resulting from research into artificial systems of emotional expression), provides a series of criteria aiding definition of performance. The performance model suggested by Clarke and Windsor (2000: 277-313) specifies six components (see table 3).
Table 3: Performance model
Source: Clarke and Windsor, 2000: 277-313
Hendrix’s performance fulfils the necessary criteria listed in Clarke and Windsor’s model. Structure is provided by the melodic and harmonic progress of the through-composed anthem; performance procedure entails the musician, his instrument and attendant processing and amplifying devices in a concert situation; pitch, rhythm, and harmonic data are encoded in the manipulation of guitar strings; an underlying pulse is present in represented metre of the musical text; structure variables include exposition of text and improvisations arising from the text; and stylistic parameters are fulfilled by characteristics of the instrument used.
1.3 Adapted Performance
With the advent of technological developments, a style of musical activity has emerged which underpins the foundations for what is determined in this discussion as tempomorphic musical practice. This activity is a combination of technology and aesthetics reflected in Cage’s observation that ‘magnetic tape music makes it clear that we are in time itself, not in measures of two, three, or four or any other number’ (1978: 70). Cage’s observation perhaps refers to his own and others’ work in the genre of musique concréte, but examples cited here are from the work of a subsequent generation of composers, indicating a clear developmental lineage. This lineage, reflecting an emergent compositional and performance style, has developed from the experimental tape loops of Steve Reich’s ‘It’s Gonna Rain’ (1966) and the introduction of 'Frippertronics' (No Pussyfooting Eno and Fripp. E.G. Records, 1973), to the digitally recorded soundscapes of The Gates of Paradise (Fripp, 1997). Each of these examples may be seen to have contributed to specific musical developments: Reich’s compositional style including features of rhythmic phasing; the establishment of ‘ambient music’ (Eno, 1996: 293); and the development of soundscaping as a recorded performance process. An example of Frippertronics - a title chosen for its silliness, according to Fripp (LaFosse, 2002) - is to be found on Fripp’s ‘Water Music I’ (Exposure, 1979), used in a musique concréte style to complement an overdubbed speech. The electro-acoustic process on which Frippertronics is based involves the introduction of a signal to a tape loop which is then repeated and added to by the performer, building sonic textures for an indefinite (and theoretically infinite) duration (see diagram 1).
Diagram 1: Tape loop schematic for Frippertronics
Source: Tamm, 1995: 152
The system illustrated by diagram 1 represents that which was used to achieve the repeated loops of Frippertronics found on such recordings as The Heavenly Music Corporation. The overall harmony of The Heavenly Music Corporation, according to Eric Tamm’s analysis, is pandiatonic (1995: 153). The resulting harmony from the performance process used by Fripp is, to use the Meyer’s third term of analysis (see above), a syntactical characteristic of tempomorphic performance.
While this recorded performance process includes aspects of conventional improvisation and recording approaches, it may be possible to identify further defining characteristics describing a procedure that transcends either convention. The sensuous impact of The Heavenly Music Corporation reflects criteria referred to by Eno in his description of a continuous music with no surprises. Aesthetic characteristics of the performance process involved in soundscaping are commented on by Robert Fripp:
Soundscape performances are part of an ongoing series of discovery which has the aim of finding ways in which intelligence and music, definition and discovery, courtesy and reciprocation may enter into the act of music for both musician and audience (1997: 4).
A governing aesthetic relating to feedback loops between the performer and that performed is clear in Fripp’s statement. Further specific issues it is necessary for the musician to address in soundscape performance arise from the opportunity for empirical evaluation and development of the work as it progresses. Features of tempomorphic performance, including observed characteristics of soundscaping, are included in table 4.
Table 4: Characteristics of tempomorphic performance
Source: empirical observations of research (Doyle, unpublished paper, 2002)
The following empirical observations, based on the findings of practical research, address each characteristic of tempomorphism and are briefly outlined following the order in which they appear in table 4.
Three concluding observations regarding tempomorphic performance refer to feedback immediacy, characteristics of computer-based music-making, and conventional performance technique. Firstly, a governing aspect of tempomorphic performance is that the performer listens to loops created, representing a shrinking of the addresser/addressee feedback loop. These observations regarding short-term empiricism have been made above, and are repeated here to emphasise their perceived impact on performance. Secondly, these characteristics stem from the particular temporal characteristics of looped information (a feature of computer sequencing), and find earlier precedent in Satie’s proposed ‘inconsequential’ aesthetic of ‘furniture music’ (Griffiths, 1994: 68).  Thirdly, technical innovations complement established performance techniques to manipulate the perception of passing time such as rubato, wherein a performer ‘steals time’ from the metre in order to enhance the character of a phrase or passage. Rubato has been described as the ‘mark of a living organism’ (Scruton, 1997: 24). It is a characteristic of loop systems that the mark of a living organism is repeated with the precision of a machine.
2 Present: examples
By concentrating on behaviour rather than results, and process rather than product, Cage had helped to create a basis for dialogue between all the arts, a recognition that ideas held in common were more important than purely local differences of media (Eno and Mills, 1986: 42).
Whether the artwork as process indicates a particular stylistic movement, such as Modernism or Postmodernism, is a matter for debate elsewhere. However, as Meyer has commented, the way of listening to a composition by one composer can be radically different to the way of listening required by another (1967: 87). Composition and performance is facilitated by continuing technological developments making use of precise temporal sampling. This highlights our perception of a sampled event, and how we may refer to it depending on its context. Although an objective assessment of a digital sample may find that it is a stereo audio file with a16-bit resolution lasting for 1.2 seconds, it might also be perceived subjectively as a fragment, moment, event, chord, or a holon (Koestler, 1968: 105). 
2.1 Tempomorphism in practice
A tempomorphic methodology may be observed in approaches to composition using looped sequences in programmes such as Emagic Logic, resulting in construction using a series of contrasting but contiguous measures. These measures, as a result of their size and the copy and paste features of computer software, provide holons influencing the overall dynamic structure of the piece.
Using the example of ‘Bohemian Like You’ (Taylor-Taylor, 2000), two copy and paste hypermeasure characteristics become apparent. The first characteristic has to do with the use of sampling to build structure, while the second emphasises sample content. The arrangement of ‘Bohemian Like You’ shows a structural reliance on hierarchies of looped metric hierarchies, or hypermeasures. The introduction to the song depends on a looped, African-sounding drum pattern for a statement of pulse and cultural location, which is then developed with a copy and paste expansion into a soundworld derivative of The Rolling Stones in the late-1960s. The development of an original Keith Richards riff (as the result of harmonic variation) reflects use of sampling to reinterpret previous material, such interpretation providing transposition of textual and cultural identity into a new context. This example, in addition to the wide variety of music software available and in use both domestically and professionally, shows how the adoption of an approach to music-making based on repeated loops, or tempomorphism, is established practice in some areas.
The discussion here has focused on technological aspects of tempomorphic music-making rather than its performance. The impact of electro-acoustic music on performance suggests the need for an enhancement of visual aspects of a performance event. Aspects of electro-acoustic music in performance have been viewed as problematic, as, to suggest a hypothetical example, in an extreme situation the audience may simply bear witness to a performer pressing the start control of a tape-machine. Making reference to the electro-acoustic musics of Beriot, Cage, Ligeti, Stockhausen, and Varése, the following stipulates three disadvantages of such music in performance:
Perhaps the most crucial way in which electro-acoustic music disturbs the conventional processes of western music is in its tendency either to remove or radically alter the role of the performer. The possibility inherent in this medium for a composer to deal directly with sound material, and to address his audience with only the mechanical and, ideally, neutral intermediary of a sound production system, was seen as an advantage, as is apparent in many of the views quoted earlier. But there are a number of counterbalancing disadvantages: (1) the lack of a visual element in the concert situation; (2) the lack of a sense of human effort and involvement; (3) the lack of the creative potential of the secondary process of interpretation, which in other music lends a desirable vitality and individuality to successive performances, including the unquantifiable but nevertheless important element of feedback between performer and audience which reinforces the transactional, ritualistic nature of the event (Bridger, 1986: 46).
2.2 Practical research: Methodology
2.3 Practical research: Actions
The resulting CD of tempomorphic performances comprises three pieces:
‘Tempomorphilation’ is a compilation of tempomorphic studies. ‘Metre Made’, ‘Study’, and ‘Hypermeasure’ used analogue recording media. ‘Delay Piece’, ‘Two Loops’ and ‘Maybe’ were recorded direct to DAT. The six pieces are joined as the result of feedback received regarding initial recordings from Brunel music technology lecturer Ben Jarlett (see below). The word play in the title of the compilation is the result of reading McLuhan and Fore’s The Medium is the Massage (1967). ‘Metre Made’ is a preconceived chord progression concerned with the use of a pivotal E major 7th chord in the teleological sequence from the dominant B to tonic E. The additional exploration of texture offered by digital delay provided the ‘missing’ compositional element. ‘Delay Piece’ takes its title from the process used to perform it. Similarly, ‘Two Loops’ is a performance derived from improvising over a first and second loop, the second being determined by the length of the first, but containing different pitch-material. ‘Study’ is the result of performing while positioned between two amplifiers (with respective speakers), with microphones placed to achieve maximum separation of the signal appearing from each speaker.
Diagram 2: Tempomorphic performance system
‘Maybe’ explores the potential of a pre-composed cyclic riff. ‘Hypermeasure’ was recorded to analogue two-track (with a resulting feature of tape-compression) with the aim of exploring extensions of phrase and measure into hypermeasures as defined by Epstein (1995: 29-35). ‘Diminished Space’ is the result of a performance concerned with the use of the tonality suggested by a diminished chord, decided prior to performance. ‘Bound’ is concerned with maintaining an emergent timbral and textural position as the result of hearing the initial ostinato, fractured through a disparity between loop-length and ostinato phrase-length.
Secondly, compositions for the Brunel New Music Ensemble (B.N.M.E.) provide further research material for the investigation into tempomorphic performance. The nature of performance is subject to the provision of through-composed material in the form of two pieces: ’Something Will Be Found’ (Doyle, 2000) and ‘Metre Made’ (Doyle 2001). The composition process of these pieces are informed by results of research into nested temporal hierarchies and recording processes, and presented to players of the B.N.M.E. using conventional staff notation. Therefore, ’Something Will Be Found’ is concerned with the representation of temporal hierarchies, while ‘Metre Made’ is concerned with the scored interpretation of a tempomorphic performance (see above).
2.3.1 Notes for ‘Something Will Be Found’: A representation of six nested temporal hierarchies for tuned percussion, strings and wind (Doyle, 2000)
This piece forms part of a research project exploring the relationship between perceived temporalities and their representation in the experience of music. The title is taken from an Oblique Strategy: 'Once the search is in progress, something will be found' (Eno and Schmidt, 1975).  The six temporal hierarchies reflected in this piece are: Atemporal; Prototemporal; Eotemporal; Biotemporal; Nootemporal; and Sociotemporal. The biotemporal is represented by the opening ostinato (scored for piano, but can be played on any tuned percussion instrument). It is suggested that any understanding of alternative temporalities will necessarily commence from the biological viewpoint of our species, and progress forwards (towards the sociotemporal) and backwards (towards the atemporal) from this bipedal point. An element of improvisation may prove interesting to include, based upon the rhythm of the biotemporal ostinato, between, for example, bars 65 and 91. This might be desirable to achieve additional textural and dynamic energy, as well as commitment in performance. Dynamics are to be decided during rehearsal. The representation of six nested temporalities provide the underlying building blocks for this piece, and it is from these representations (especially the use of ‘nootemporal’ thirteen-bar cells) that an overall structure is derived. Each temporality is represented in the table below.
Table 5: Representation of six nested temporalities in 'Something will be found' (Doyle, 2000)
2.3.2 Notes on the composition of 'Metre Made' (Doyle, 2001)
The tempomorphic composition of ‘Metre Made’ as a recorded performance from which was derived material for a through-composed piece for the B.N.M.E. reflects relationships of public and private time compositions in performance.
Issues arising from this process include the effect on the compositional development of a piece which acquired a dual identity as both a plastic composition and a realised score. A further issue involves the adaptation of material for use in situations with differing temporal criteria i.e. the recording of a unilateral performance in contrast with an ensemble of performers. This issue highlights the requirements of graphic representation to reflect temporal values, specifically to support a number of individuals operating by necessity in a shared temporality. The composition of this piece provides areas for personal reflection regarding such issues as the problematic area of assessing the temporal perceptions of the performer(s); the awareness of public time represented by focus of repeated simple metre, shared and contributed to by individual instruments; and observed differences between social (and therefore public) factors surrounding and dictating aspects of a piece for ensemble, compared with the temporalities of a single individual. My empirical conclusions regarding a perceived ‘shared awareness’ of public time focus on the role of the conductor, which in turn relate to perceived differences between conducted public time for the ensemble and clock time. Further reflection suggests the possibility of substituting the ensemble for the individual.
Questions specific to the performance of Metre Made could be addressed, such as with regard to the repeated ostinato in the piano part: conceived to fulfil the role of a contiguous, separate temporality emergent from shared temporality – public time – of the piece, operating parallel to and independently of the metric 'body'. Does the operation of this emergent temporality impact on the performance of members of the ensemble, and if so, how does this impact manifest itself? Does an impact take place in the performance of particular individuals? If an error occurs in the performance of the individual part's metric value, how much is this attributable to the emergent contiguous temporality?
At the time of writing this survey, performers of the B.N.M.E. have not been addressed with these questions, although there is some evidence of individual response to performance issues available in audio recordings of performances, awaiting analysis. A method of appraising individual responses among performers, for example using a questionnaire, has yet to be formulated and executed, and is likely to encounter problems of interpretation in the part of both the addresser and the addressee.
The question as to how much a performer may be identified as separate from an audience member at any stage in the performance process may result in the placement of the performer in the position of the ‘ultimate’ audience. Some findings point to the roles of performer and audience as sharing the same process (Edwards, 1997: 19), precluding the necessity for a survey of the temporal perceptions of performers.
Finally, live performance generates research material concerned with addressing such issues as the visual interpretation of tempomorphic procedure. The use of guitar and processing equipment is appended with the addition of a slide projector (Liminal conference, Twickenham, 2000). For this event, 43 transparencies are used, featuring portraits, each slide being shown for ten seconds before being changed by a technician. The additional ‘human factor’ of portraits and the technician’s judgement of projection timings are perceived to have an impact on syntactical performance by the practitioner (myself). The recording of the performance on video tape affords subsequent empirical evaluation. The liminal position of myself as combined performer and audience is apparent from the images captured on video, as, in near-darkness, I share the audience view of projected slides from a comparative perspective with the audience represented by the video camera. The convention of improvisation is more evident in this performance, where the placement of the performer in surroundings alternate to those dedicated to the processing of audio signals brings additional factors to the event. Signal volume, for example, is judged according to spatial acoustic considerations rather than to facilitate optimum recording levels. An emphasis on the representation of a given temporal hierarchy, such as the prototemporal, is replaced with an awareness of representing the temporality of the current event in relation to the projected image, and the subjective performance response to that image. The possibility of rejecting the performance (an option available when evaluating recordings for processing to CD) is removed, resulting in the presence of a tension absent from an event without an immediate external audience.
2.4 Practical research: Initial observations
Performances of compositions by the B.N.M.E. reflect issues related to conventional performance practice. This practice includes a dependence on rehearsal time for the ensemble, the interpretation of text, communication between members, and ‘aleatoric’ compositional results of interpretation, not necessarily a direct result of the composer’s intention. Feedback loops between the composer and performer/s, the composer and the audience, the performers and the audience, are each of conventional and, in comparison to tempomorphic feedback, extended length.
The tempomorphic performance at the Liminal conference (Twickenham, 2000) used slide projections to enhance visual aspects of performance. Video recordings of the event demonstrate what might be interpreted as a ‘minimal effort’ on behalf of the performer, underpinning Bridger’s observation regarding the ‘lack of a sense of human effort and involvement’ in performance observed by the audiences of electro-acoustic musics (Bridger, 1986: 46). Issues relating to the provision of visual information intended to complement and enhance live tempomorphic performance suggest an area of further research investigation, and are discussed below.
2.5 Actions to be considered
2.6 Empirical observation of tempomorphic performance practice
As pieces evolve, concern may focus on providing weight to the soundscape, in the form of lower pitched tones, or multiple voicings of mid-range clusters, or on extending and framing a particular motive, frequently of higher pitch. A preliminary empirical conclusion from the results of practical research suggests that music composed focussing on looped temporal elements becomes music featuring textural colour. This appears to be true both for tempomorphic recordings and compositions for the B.N.M.E.
3 Future: Implications
To conclude this survey, I would like to provide an evaluation of findings: a review of cognitive impact on performance; comments on emergent sociotemporal features of the twentieth century; problems of atemporality; and aesthetic implications of temporal awareness.
3.1 Evaluation of findings
Definitions of tempomorphic performance have proven to depend on the perception of tempomorphism and alternative temporalities by the performer. Given that temporality is a cognitive phenomenon, the impact on performance derived from temporal perception is in the way the performer uses aesthetic language to inform his work. In addition to these conclusions, I suggest tempomorphic perception offers a model for a universal listening strategy, in addition to (or conceivably in place of) interpretative strategies dependent upon stylistic and cultural foreknowledge. Accepting the interpretation of musical works as soundscapes, the perceived evocation of a temporal umwelt by that soundscape is the result of a tempomorphic process in the part of the subject.
3.3 Comments on emergent sociotemporal features of the twentieth century
3.4 Problems of atemporality
However, the success with which the temporal art can depict atemporal, or non-moving, time (dependent, as the perception of non-moving time is, on the perceptions of the beholder) may come through an evocation of the atemporal umwelt. It is atemporality which is described by Kramer when he defines vertical music as ‘a holistic music that offers a timeless temporal continuum, in which the linear interrelationships between past, present, and future are suspended’ (1988: 387). The possibility of evoking atemporality is further supported by the view that time unfolds at the speed at which information is processed (Barry, 1990: 165), suggesting that limited, repeated information requires little processing and therefore, according to this theory, results in a perceived reduction in the unfolding speed of time. An alternative theory indicating the possibility of atemporality in the experience of music is found in the view of Robin George Collingwood, suggesting that music as a ‘work of art’ may exist ‘solely in the musician’s head’ (Ayer, 1984: 195).
3.5 Aesthetic implications of temporal awareness
Findings of research regarding individual and cultural concepts of temporality suggest alternative criteria of temporal measurement are to be found in variances between time experienced by the individual and time perceived by the immediate culture within which the individual operates (Kramer, 1988: 15; Hall, 1984: 13). The inclusion of cultural criteria in the evaluation of the area of research necessitates a broad field of interdisciplinary study. Music-making, dependent upon perceptions of temporality for its operation, reflects multiple temporalities such as the representation of pattern against suggested pulse (in syntactical terms), as well as associative-characterizing languages associating certain music with specific styles for the participant (Meyer 1967: 34).
Research actions have underpinned a perceived complementary relationship between music and time, evident in the composition of music using criteria of a perceived temporal nature resulting in the generation of musics for a variety of media, dependant on the relationships of syntax, culture, and individual interpretation ('Metre Made', Doyle, 2001). Findings of this investigation are subject to interpretation from a musicological perspective, while acknowledging Heidegger, who has suggested that the search for a specific will result in data relative to that specific, according to perceptions of the individual subject (1995: 275).
Tempomorphic performance characteristics have been compared to a model of 'conventional' performance, although perception of a given style of an art form is arguably dependant upon the foreknowledge of the perceiver, or the 'share of the beholder' (Gombrich, 1968: 169). One musical (and interdisciplinary) style foregrounded by research is that of Minimalism, representing an evolving stylistic movement underpinning musical developments of the late twentieth century: 'As Terry Riley observed, the restless inquietude of European avant-garde music had never been able to give the world those moments of peace which were its greatest current need' (Polin, 1989: 229). The minimalist nature of the tempomorphic musical form, featuring an absence of conventional variation and development, serves to reaffirm Cage’s observation, quoted once again, regarding music recorded on magnetic audio tape, that ‘we are not in measures of two, three, four or any other number, but in time itself’ (1976: 70).
Ayer, Alfred. Philosophy in the Twentieth Century. London: Unwin, 1984.
Barry, Barbara. Musical Time New York: Pendragon Press, 1990.
Borst, Clive. A Companion to Epistemology Ed. Jonathan Dancy and Ernest Sosa. Oxford: Blackwell, 1993. 485-6.
Bridger, Michael. Evolving musical style thesis-structural, expressive and contextual aspects of selected electro-acoustic compositions by Berio, Cage, Ligeti, Stockhausen and Varese. Ph.D., University of Keele, 1986.
Broadhurst, Susan. Liminal Acts: A Critical Overview of Contemporary Performance and Theory London: Cassel, 1999.
Cage, John. Silence Middletown, Connecticut: Wesleyan University Press, 1976.
Clarke, Eric F. and Windsor, W. Luke. ‘Real and Simulated Expression: A Listening Study’ Music Perception, Spring 2000, Vol. 17, No. 3, 277-313.
Copland, Aaron. Music and Imagination London: Harvard University Press, 1952.
Crichton, Michael. Quoted by Rosenthal, Mark. Dancers on a Plane London: Anthony d'Offay Gallery, 1989.
Descartes, René. A Discourse on Method London: Dent, 1994.
Doyle, Robert. 'Bound.' Tempomorphilation. BMG, 2002.
- - - 'Diminished Space.' Tempomorphilation. BMG, 2002.
- - - Metre Made. BMG, 2001.
- - - Something will be found. BMG, 2000.
- - - Tempomorphilation. BMG, 2002.
- - -'Delay piece.' Tempomorphilation. BMG, 2002.
- - -'Maybe.' Tempomorphilation. BMG, 2002.
- - -'Metre made.' Tempomorphilation. BMG, 2002.
- - -'Study.' Tempomorphilation. BMG, 2002.
- - -'Two loops.' Tempomorphilation. BMG, 2002.
- - -'Hypermeasure.' Tempomorphilation. BMG, 2002.
Edwards, Barry. Watching What People Are, London: Optik, 1997.
Eno, Brian. Ambient 1: Music for Airports Editions E.G., 1979.
Eno, Brian. Discreet Music Editions E.G., 1975.
Eno, Brian. A Year with Swollen Appendices London: Faber and Faber, 1996.
Eno, Brian. 'The Big Here and the Long Now' 23 January 2002.
Eno, Brian and Robert Fripp. No Pussyfooting E.G. Records Ltd., 1973.
Eno, Brian and Russell Mills. More Dark Than Shark London: Faber and Faber, 1986.
Eno, Brian and Schmidt, Peter. Oblique Strategies: Over 100 worthwhile dilemmas by Brian Eno and Peter Schmidt London: Apollo, 1975.
Epstein, Brian. Shaping Time New York: Schirmer, 1995.
Fraisse, Paul. ‘Rhythm and Tempo’ The Psychology of Music Ed. Diana Deutsche London: Academic Press, 1982.
Fraser, J.T. The Genesis and Evolution of Time Great Britain: Harvester Press, 1982.
Fripp, Robert. The Gates of Paradise. Discipline Global Mobile, 1997.
Fripp, Robert. Exposure E.G. Records Ltd., 1979.
Griffiths, Paul: Modern Music London: Thames and Hudson, 1994.
Gleick, James. Faster London: Little, Brown, 1999.
Gombrich, Ernst. H. Art and Illusion London: Phaidon Press, 1968.
Hall, Edward T. The Dance of Life: The Other Dimension of Time New York: Doubleday Anchor, 1984.
Hawking, Stephen. A Brief History of Time Great Britain: Transworld, 1988.
Heidegger, Martin. Being and Time Trans. from Sein und Zeit (7th edition) Oxford: Blackwell Publishers Ltd., 1995.
Hendrix, Jimi. ‘The Star Spangled Banner’ Woodstock MCA, 1994.
Juslin and Madison. ‘The Role of Timing Patterns in Recognition of Emotional Expression’, Music Perception, Winter 1999, Vol.17, No.2, 197-221.
Koestler, Arthur. The Ghost in the Machine New York: Macmillan, 1968.
Kramer, Johnathan D. The Time of Music New York: Schirmer, 1988.
LaFosse, Andre. 1 March 2002
Meyer, Leonard B. Music, the Arts, and Ideas: Patterns and predictions in Twentieth-Century culture London: University of Chicago Press, 1967.
Mondrian, Piet. Broadway Boogie Woogie. 1942-3 Museum of Modern Art, New York.
Mitchell, Donald. The Language of Modern Music London: Faber and Faber, 1963.
Polin, Claire. 'Why Minimalism Now?' Music and the Politics of Culture Ed. Christopher Norris London: Lawrence and Wishart, 1989.
Prendergast, Mark. The Ambient Century London: Bloomsbury, 2000.
Read, Herbert. A Concise History of Modern Painting London: Thames and Hudson, 1968.
Reich, Steve. ‘It’s Gonna Rain’ Early Works Elektra/Nonesuch, 1987.
Rosenthal, Mark. '”Dancers on a Plane”' and other stratagems for inclusion in the work of Jasper Johns’ Dancers on a Plane. London: Anthony d'Offay Gallery, 1989.
Russell, Bertrand. The Existence of Matter, The Problems of Philosophy, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1967.
Schenker, Heinrich. Harmony London: MIT Press, 1973.
Scruton, Roger. The Aesthetics of Music Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1997.
Small, Christopher. Musicking – the means of performing and listening. A lecture. Music Education Research, Vol.1, No.1, 1999.
Tamm, Eric. Brian Eno, his music and the vertical colour of sound New York: Da Capo Press, Inc, 1995.
Taylor-Taylor, Courtney. ‘Bohemian Like You’ Thirteen Tales from Urban Bohemia Capitol, 2000.
Turner, Victor. ‘Are there Universals of Performance in Myth, Ritual, and Drama?’ By Means of Performance Ed. Richard Schechner and Willa Appel. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990.
Von UexKüll, Jakob. ’A stroll through the world of animals and men’ in Instinctive Behaviour, trans./ed. Claire Schiller New York: International Universities Press, 1957.
Wellek, Albert. ‘The Psychology of Music Hearing’ Main Trends in Aesthetics and the Sciences of Art. Ed. Mikel Dufrenne. New York: Holmes and Meier, 1979.115-121.
 The use of the term tempomorphic to refer to the study of varieties of perceived temporalities, or forms of time, reflects terminology used in other disciplines, such as the investigation of land forms, and referred to as geomorphic study.
 The relationship between time and perception is identified by Fraisse as relating to the perception of order: ‘Rhythm is the perception of order. One of the perceptual aspects of rhythmic organization is tempo. It can be lively or slow. It corresponds to the number of perceived elements per unit time, or to the absolute duration of the different values of the durations. Evidently, one passed from a definition based on frequency to a perception based on duration. We will use both of them. The possibility of rhythmic perception depends on tempo, because the organization of succession into perceptible patterns is largely determined by the law of proximity. When the tempo slows down too much, the rhythm and also the melody disappear’ (1982:151)
 See, for example, Scruton (1997) for a discussion of matters relating to aesthetics and music, wherein the distinction is made early in the debate between that which is material and that which is intentional (1997: 4).
 For a comprehensive appraisal of species-specific temporal universes, defined as ‘Umwelts’, see Von UexKüll (1957).
 In a hermeneutic circle, Heidegger proposes, the participant’s foreknowledge of characteristics effects observations made by the participant to the extent that in knowing certain characteristics, defining aspects of those characteristics will be found by the participant in that which is observed. Heidegger writes in Being and Time: ‘Ontological investigation is a possible kind of interpreting, which we have described as the working-out and appropriation of an understanding. Every interpretation has its fore-having, its fore-sight, and its fore-conception. If such an interpretation, as Interpretation, becomes an explicit task for research, then the totality of these 'presuppositions' (which we call the hermeneutical Situation) needs to be clarified and made secure beforehand, both in a basic experience of the 'object' to be disclosed, and in terms of such an experience’ (1995: 275).
 See Griffiths (1994) for further information on Nancarrow.
 This music was realised by Honegger, Poulenc and Milhaud, members of ‘Les Six’, with works such as ‘Musique d’ameublement’.
 .’A holon is a more or less separable entity or event that forms part of a hierarchic structure. For instance, a motive would be a holon on a low level; a theme would be one on a higher level.’
 Hierarchical, plastic, and reductionist are use here as respectively defining concepts of nested perceptually prioritised levels (as of temporality), adaptable characteristics regarding the generation of form, and the applied reduction of component parts of a form.
 'Oblique Strategies' is the title given to a set of cards, each bearing an aphorism to be applied in a creative situation at the user's discretion. 'The deck, which Eno developed and produced in collaboration with his painter friend Peter Schmidt, is a set of oracle cards modelled philosophically on the ancient Chinese I Ching, or Book of Changes' (Tamm, 1995:77).
 Broadhurst, Susan. ‘Interaction, Reaction and Performance: The human body tracking project’ Body, Space and Technology, 2, June 2001. http://www.brunel.ac.uk
Rob Doyle was awarded an MA at Middlesex University in 1999.
Further study for the completion of a doctoral thesis is informed by the practice and teaching of music.
This paper constitutes outcomes of practical and academic postgraduate research undertaken at Brunel University. Contributing material (including performance material) was presented at the Liminality and Performance Conference, Brunel University, Twickenham, UK, April 2000.
Compositions and performances have been recorded and published by Rough Trade, Island, and BMG, and presented via the ICA and Channel 4.